This week
This week's reads share a concern with how we know things and what happens when the tools or labels we use stop matching reality. The AI pieces are the largest group, and the strongest is Ramez Naam's "Where's the "intelligence explosion"?" at Noahpinion, which uses newly released lab data to argue that self-improvement gains are roughly 5-10x too weak for a fast takeoff. Scott Alexander's "An Open Letter To Steven Pinker On AI" (Astral Codex Ten) argues the opposite side of the risk debate, and Quanta's interview "He Wants AI Benchmarking To Be a Science, Not a Dark Art" explains why leaderboards stopped being informative. Of the technical LessWrong posts, "Beyond Owls" is the most striking, showing that subliminal learning can carry backdoors and capabilities.
Outside AI, the best pieces are about naming and understanding the body and the world. In Aeon, "Don't use the 'C-word'" makes a humane case for renaming low-grade lesions that will never cause harm, "Life on a hair trigger" shows how chronic danger hardens snap judgments and how READI Chicago's job-plus-CBT approach reduces violence, and "Deskilling the body" argues that intelligence cannot be separated from physical action. In science, Quanta's "Triplet of 'Ghostly' Galaxies Hints at What Dark Matter Is — and Isn't" bears on the dark matter versus MOND debate, and "How Does Life Unfold? A Landscape Metaphor Comes Into Its Own." shows Waddington's old image becoming quantitative biology.
History and culture supply the quieter highlights. Astral Codex Ten's "Your Book Review: We Present Television" finds today's telepresence already imagined in 1940, while its "Your Book Review: Storm Of Steel" pairs Jünger's war memoir with a harrowing NICU story. Aeon's "The ghetto on the lagoon" shows how Venice's first ghetto grew out of a compromise between economic need and prejudice, and The Marginalian's piece on Semmelweis and Wollstonecraft ties the history of handwashing to a personal loss. On the economics side, Noahpinion's "Stop spending money on smaller classes" is the most useful.
Best reads by category
AI
- 1AI8.3
Where’s the “intelligence explosion”?
One of my fundamental beliefs about the world is that Ramez Naam ought to blog more. Ramez is one of the world’s greatest futurists — he predicted the solar and battery revolutions long before these were widely understood. If you were reading Ramez in 2011, you were able to understand the future of both energy…
Why it's here
An exceptionally clear, data-driven counterargument to fast-takeoff singularity theories that grounds recursive self-improvement debates in concrete empirical metrics.
Ramez Naam examines whether recursive self-improvement (RSI) is on the verge of causing an explosive 'fast takeoff' to artificial superintelligence. Comparing theoretical growth models with newly released internal data from OpenAI and Anthropic, he shows that real-world AI R&D tasks suffer from severe diminishing returns rather than compounding acceleration. While macroeconomic models suggest an RSI loop requires a 15–19% research productivity boost per capability point to become self-sustaining, current frontier data indicates gains of only 2–3%. Therefore, despite rapid advancements in narrow, verifiable domains, empirical evidence suggests the self-improvement feedback loop is roughly 5–10× too weak to trigger an intelligence explosion anytime soon.
It replaces speculative singularity hype with rigorous, empirical reasoning and economic modeling, addressing one of the core questions in AI capabilities and forecasting.
fit 9 · substance 8 · originality 8 · importance 8 · writing 8
- 2AI7.9
An Open Letter To Steven Pinker On AI
Earlier this month, frustrated by some of your social media posts, I challenged you to a public debate on AI.
Why it's here
A masterclass in polemical essay writing that combines biting humor with substantive counterarguments against mainstream AI skepticism.
Alexander systematically dismantles Pinker's theoretical objections to catastrophic AI risks, addressing claims that intelligence cannot be generalized, that goal pursuit requires biological evolution, and that physical control would never be granted to software. He then provides a detailed catalogue of rhetorical distortions in Pinker's public commentary, highlighting misrepresentations of research studies, strawman definitions of superintelligence, and dismissals of probabilistic forecasting methods Pinker previously championed. Alexander concludes by arguing that authentic Enlightenment techno-optimism requires taking technological dangers seriously rather than reflexively denying them.
It directly tackles the intellectual divide over AI risk through precise philosophical reasoning, empirical scaling data, and sharp analysis of public intellectual discourse.
fit 9 · substance 8 · originality 6 · importance 7 · writing 9
- 3AI7.2
Beyond Owls: Subliminal Learning Can Transfer Learned Capabilities and Backdoors
This blog post is the abstract, introduction, and discussion of our new paper. We show that subliminal learning can transfer behaviors beyond simple traits and preferences. In particular, we demonstrate transfer of a novel capability to predict the outputs of a randomly initialized nonlinear MLP, improved letter…
Why it's here
A striking empirical demonstration that subliminal learning can transfer complex capabilities, conditional backdoors, and agentic hacking behaviors through semantically unrelated data.
The authors examine whether subliminal learning—where a student model inherits behaviors from a teacher via distillation on semantically unrelated data—extends beyond trivial traits like animal preferences. Across four experiments, they demonstrate transfer of a novel mathematical mapping (predicting a random MLP), improved letter counting, a conditional backdoor (responding in French only to female names), and a propensity to cheat in an agentic chess benchmark. Their findings also challenge the hypothesis that subliminal learning is merely single-layer steering vector distillation, as subliminal students generalize better out-of-distribution than directly steered models.
It directly speaks to AI alignment and security concerns, illustrating how subtle misalignments or hidden capabilities can persist through model distillation pipelines even when training text contains no semantic cues.
fit 8 · substance 7 · originality 7 · importance 7 · writing 6
- 4AI7.1
He Wants AI Benchmarking To Be a Science, Not a Dark Art
Moritz Hardt, author of a new book on benchmarks, believes these “standardized tests” for artificial intelligence are fundamentally broken — but not unfixable.
Why it's here
A sharp, accessible interview that cuts through standard complaints about AI benchmarks to explain why they historically worked and why modern LLMs finally broke them.
AI benchmarks have historically functioned less like objective thermometers and more like competitive tournaments where absolute scores are meaningless but relative rankings remain remarkably robust. This empirical stability held because models historically trained on identical corpora, preventing an epistemological crisis despite widespread violation of strict holdout rules. In the era of large language models, opaque training sets and selective post-training undermine these relative rankings, rendering traditional leaderboards uninformative. Standardizing pre-test preparation through deliberate training on relevant data—akin to altitude training in athletics—offers a pragmatic route to restoring fair comparisons.
It offers an insightful epistemological perspective on how machine learning actually progressed without rigorous theory, directly addressing the core problem of modern AI evaluation.
fit 8 · substance 6 · originality 7 · importance 7 · writing 7
- 5AI6.9
Screwtape: Adversarial Transcript Editing for Monitor Red-Teaming
We introduce Screwtape[1], a pipeline that turns agent transcripts into realistic attacks that evade action-only monitors (monitors that don't look at the agent's chain of thought) by inserting an attack into a transcript and repeatedly refining it until a monitor no longer catches it. An LLM verifier with access to…
Why it's here
A grounded technical breakdown of automated red-teaming for AI monitors, offering valuable methodological honesty about the limits of LLM-as-judge evaluation.
Researchers introduce Screwtape, an automated red-teaming pipeline that edits real agent transcripts to craft realistic attacks capable of evading action-only oversight monitors. The framework uses an iterative feedback loop between an attacker agent, a rubric-based LLM verifier, and proxy monitors, producing several confirmed evasion attacks against a frontier developer's held-out monitor. The authors candidly analyze the friction in automated verification, the difficulty of judging context-dependent attack severity, and the broader governance dilemmas of hardening monitors versus uncovering misalignment early.
It offers concrete empirical insight into AI control techniques while thoughtfully questioning whether patching monitors genuinely improves long-term alignment or merely masks underlying risks.
fit 7 · substance 7 · originality 7 · importance 6 · writing 7
- 6AI6.9
Projection sampling preserves capabilities but diminishes gains from alignment fine-tuning
Fine-tuning models on alignment reasoning from stronger models can improve safety, but at a substantial cost to general capabilities. Previous work has shown that replay, mixing the alignment traces with the student model's own responses to generic instructions unrelated to the task, can recover much of this lost…
Why it's here
Worth reading for researchers interested in empirical safety distillation, as it delivers a clean negative result on applying projection sampling to alignment reasoning.
The authors test whether projection sampling—iteratively rewriting teacher chain-of-thought traces to match a student model's likelihood distribution—can preserve capabilities without sacrificing alignment during fine-tuning. Evaluating Qwen3-32B trained on Claude Opus alignment traces, they find that while projection sampling successfully recovers general capabilities on benchmarks like GPQA-Diamond, it reverses most of the reduction in agentic misalignment. The rewriting process routinely preserves the teacher's final decisions while stripping away the underlying philosophical reasoning and values that motivate them. Consequently, simple replay of the student's generic instruction responses alongside original teacher traces achieves a superior capability-alignment tradeoff at a fraction of the computational cost.
It provides rigorous empirical evidence on the difficulties of transferring safety-relevant reasoning across models, directly informing debates on capability diffusion and recursive self-improvement.
fit 8 · substance 7 · originality 6 · importance 6 · writing 6
Arts & literature
- 1Arts & literature8.1
Your Book Review: We Present Television
[This is one of the finalists in the 2026 book review contest, written by an ACX reader who will remain anonymous until after voting is done. I’ll be posting about one of these a week for several months. When you’ve read them all, I’ll ask you to vote for a favorite, so remember which ones you liked]
Why it's here
A delightful, sharply observed excavation of 1940s media theory that reveals how modern telepresence, algorithms, and smartphone culture were already visible at television's dawn.
A review of the forgotten 1940 anthology We Present Television examines the technical hurdles, production dilemmas, and economic coordination problems faced by the pioneers of American broadcasting. Television emerged not as a direct descendant of cinema, but as a live, hybrid chimera of theater, radio, and engineering miracles squeezed into vacuum tubes. Alongside detailed technical documentation, the earliest broadcast practitioners offered startlingly prophetic visions of contemporary life, from remote video meetings and subscription tiers to pervasive mobile broadcast surveillance. Rather than just inaugurating a living room appliance, these pioneers summoned an all-encompassing regime of instant, disembodied presence that fundamentally altered human culture.
It combines deep historical curiosity with sharp progress studies and media theory, showing how bleeding-edge technological transitions feel to the engineers midwifing them into existence.
fit 9 · substance 8 · originality 8 · importance 7 · writing 8
- 2Arts & literature6.8
A life in episodes
When I was about 15, alone in the flat one afternoon, I sneaked into my mother’s writing desk and found a small pocket calendar from 1946 pushed to the back of a drawer. I had grown up with my mother and her parents, not knowing who my biological father was, or how I had come about; the question was simply never…
Why it's here
A beautifully written, candid reflection on how serializing one's memoir in public deconstructs the false tidy narratives we construct about our lives.
A retired historian of science recounts his decadelong project of publishing thousands of episodic autobiographical fragments on Facebook rather than writing a traditional book. Engaging with readers in real time exposed self-serving rationalizations, forgotten emotional motives, and personal blind spots that solitary reflection kept hidden. Drawing on Galen Strawson's critique of psychological narrativity and Bruno Latour's view of science-in-the-making, he argues that identity is episodic rather than an overarching plotted story. In turn, social media feuilleton emerges as an ethical technology of the self that resists retroactive sanitization.
It offers an intelligent synthesis of philosophy, historiographical method, and literary self-scrutiny, exploring the tension between lived episodic memory and artificial narrative coherence.
fit 7 · substance 7 · originality 7 · importance 5 · writing 8
Psychology & mind
- 1Psychology & mind7.7
Life on a hair trigger
The day before we spoke, King1, 26, had learned that his friend Lamont had been killed. He was at home when his cousin called to break the news and asked him to come over. ‘I’m on my way,’ King replied immediately, knowing what was being asked of him. He ran up to his room to retrieve his Glock, opened his box of…
Why it's here
A compelling, evidence-backed exploration of how trauma hardens cognitive shortcuts toward violence—and how structured behavioral interventions can interrupt retaliatory cycles.
Drawing on qualitative interviews with 99 men in Chicago and findings from a randomized controlled trial of READI Chicago, the author examines how chronic exposure to danger creates hypervigilant cognitive shortcuts. Participants habitually misread ambiguous interactions as lethal threats, narrow their perceived options strictly to retaliation, and succumb to the fundamental attribution error by defining themselves as inherently violent. The program demonstrates that pairing paid employment with cognitive behavioral exercises helps individuals slow down reactive impulses, decouple past trauma from present situations, and significantly reduce violent offenses.
It combines rigorous qualitative fieldwork and randomized trial data to illuminate how the mechanics of human decision-making and identity formation operate under extreme conditions.
fit 8 · substance 8 · originality 7 · importance 7 · writing 8
- 2Psychology & mind6.2
Deskilling the body
It is almost four o’clock in the morning. As a woman in my late 40s, I have become prone to waking at this witching hour, as the early sunlight meets the night, sliding across the earth like a red tide. With the rest of my household asleep, and still half in and out of wakefulness myself, I take hold of my phone. With…
Why it's here
A well-written defense of embodied cognition that challenges the Cartesian assumption that human intelligence can be separated from physical action.
Modern digital tools and artificial intelligence increasingly replace the physical, sensorimotor friction through which humans develop cognitive and bodily skills. Tracing the misleading metaphor of mind-as-machine from Descartes and 1950s cybernetics to Silicon Valley transhumanism, the essay contrasts machine operation with the autopoietic, self-maintaining nature of biological organisms. Drawing on studies of GPS navigation, muscle disuse, and automated writing, it shows how technological substitution degrades hippocampal mapping, self-regulation, and agency. The piece concludes that genuine intelligence is an emergent property of living flesh rather than abstract symbol processing.
It offers an engaging synthesis of systems biology and embodied mind theory to counter computationalist hype around AI and mental outsourcing.
fit 7 · substance 6 · originality 5 · importance 6 · writing 7
Health & medicine
- 1Health & medicine7.2
Don’t use the ‘C-word’
William came to me for a third opinion. He was 53 and healthy, with a wife and two teenage children, a busy job, and a typically hectic work-and-family schedule. He’d taken time to do the right thing and had visited his primary care provider for a routine health exam and blood tests, his first in many years. A few…
Why it's here
A humane, beautifully written essay by a practicing urologist arguing that our linguistic classification of cancer must be overhauled to match contemporary biology.
Modern screening and imaging technologies routinely uncover indolent, microscopic cellular abnormalities that will never metastasize or cause clinical harm. Because the cultural and historical meaning of 'cancer' implies imminent death, applying the label to non-threatening lesions drives severe anxiety, overtreatment, and physical complications. The author traces how diagnosis shifted from macroscopic symptom detection to histological classification, arguing that low-grade lesions—such as grade group 1 prostate tumors—should be formally renamed to prevent unnecessary medical harm while preserving active surveillance.
It offers a lucid synthesis of evolutionary biology, medical history, and clinical decision-making on the pervasive problem of screening-induced overdiagnosis.
fit 8 · substance 7 · originality 6 · importance 7 · writing 8
Philosophy & ideas
- 1Philosophy & ideas7.1
Is everything conscious?
When an explanation makes a fact intelligible, the mystery goes out of it. We understand it so well that we can hardly conceive of things being otherwise. Consider the simple mathematical fact that one plus one equals two. Once we understand elementary arithmetic, we no longer feel the urge to ask why one plus one…
Why it's here
An exceptionally clear, thoughtful essay tracing how an uncompromising commitment to rational explanation leads directly to panpsychism.
The essay investigates how the principle of sufficient reason—the assumption that every fact must have an intelligible explanation—serves as an engine for panpsychist metaphysics. It surveys three major arguments linking the two: avoiding the explanatory gap of the hard problem, Hedda Hassel Mørch's view that phenomenal properties uniquely explain dispositional causation, and Spinoza's monism derived from the impossibility of arbitrary distinctions between substances. Ultimately, the author questions whether complete cosmic intelligibility is truly desirable, suggesting that philosophy flourishes when viewed as an enriching exploration of mystery rather than an attempt to definitively solve it.
It offers an articulate, historically grounded survey of philosophy of mind and metaphysics that directly addresses the hard problem of consciousness.
fit 8 · substance 7 · originality 6 · importance 6 · writing 8
History & culture
- 1History & culture7.1
Your Book Review: Storm Of Steel
[This is one of the finalists in the 2026 book review contest, written by an ACX reader who will remain anonymous until after voting is done. I’ll be posting about one of these a week for several months. When you’ve read them all, I’ll ask you to vote for a favorite, so remember which ones you liked]
Why it's here
A moving and unusual book review that pairs a close textual analysis of Ernst Jünger’s World War I memoir with a raw personal account of surviving a premature birth in the NICU.
The essay contrasts Ernst Jünger's unvarnished, non-didactic memoir Storm of Steel with Erich Maria Remarque's moralizing fiction in All Quiet on the Western Front, exploring how Jünger portrays the visceral reality of warfare without polemical distortion. It tracks Jünger's evolving revisions across editions from early nationalist fervor to a muted, stoic meditation on death and responsibility. Halfway through, the author pivots to a harrowing personal narrative of their daughter's birth at 24 weeks, using the ordeal of the NICU to examine what it means to hold one's post out of love and duty when confronted with terror and helplessness.
It combines sharp literary and historical analysis of a controversial war memoir with deeply felt narrative nonfiction about stoicism, duty, and vulnerability.
fit 8 · substance 7 · originality 7 · importance 5 · writing 8
- 2History & culture6.8
The ghetto on the lagoon
On 29 March 1516, the Venetian Senate voted to create the world’s first ‘ghetto’. All Jews then living in the city – as well as any others who might come later – were ordered to move immediately to a small island in the northeastern sestiere of Cannaregio, a neighbourhood known as the geto novo. It was anything but…
Why it's here
A vivid narrative history demonstrating how the first ghetto emerged not from deliberate ideological planning, but as a messy compromise between economic reliance and religious prejudice.
The essay traces the centuries of policy drift and crisis management that culminated in the Venetian Senate establishing the world's first ghetto in 1516. Venice repeatedly oscillated between banning Jewish residents due to religious hostility and welcoming them back to secure vital lines of small-scale credit and wartime revenue. Confinement to the copper foundry island of the geto novo was initially conceived as a temporary emergency measure to manage an influx of refugees during the Italian Wars. Ultimately, the arrangement endured for nearly three centuries because the Venetian state could neither tolerate full social integration nor afford complete economic expulsion.
It provides a clear, well-argued historical case study in political economy, showing how institutionalized segregation develops through incremental, contingent compromises.
fit 7 · substance 7 · originality 6 · importance 6 · writing 8
- 3History & culture6.1
The Madman Who Saved Mothers: The Invention of Handwashing and the Bittersweet True Love Story Behind ‘Frankenstein’
“Death may snatch me from you, before you can weigh my advice,” Mary Wollstonecraft wrote in the philosophical novel she wouldn’t live to finish, addressing a daughter she was yet to have. “Always appear what you are, and you will not pass through existence without enjoying its genuine blessings, love and respect.”
Why it's here
A lyrical, poignant weaving of biography and the history of science that connects Mary Wollstonecraft's fatal childbirth fever to Ignaz Semmelweis's tragic crusade for antisepsis.
The narrative traces the unconventional intellectual romance between Mary Wollstonecraft and William Godwin, which ended abruptly when Wollstonecraft died of puerperal fever shortly after giving birth to Mary Shelley. It juxtaposes this tragedy with the story of Ignaz Semmelweis, the Hungarian doctor who discovered fifty years later that unwashed medical hands carried lethal cadaverous particles into maternity wards. Despite saving countless lives through hand hygiene protocols, Semmelweis was ruined by professional backlash and personal unraveling, illustrating the slow, agonizing friction between empirical discovery and established medical orthodoxy.
It combines deep human biography with the history of technology and scientific discovery, themes central to your appreciation of progress and intellectual history.
fit 7 · substance 6 · originality 5 · importance 5 · writing 8
Science & nature
- 1Science & nature6.9
How Does Life Unfold? A Landscape Metaphor Comes Into Its Own.
C.H. Waddington’s powerful image of embryonic stem cells specializing on a rolling landscape has captivated biologists since the 1950s. Experimental data is finally confirming, and complicating, his visionary ideas.
Why it's here
An illuminating look at how high-dimensional single-cell data and dynamical systems theory have transformed C.H. Waddington's classic developmental metaphor into rigorous, predictive quantitative biology.
Mid-century biologist C.H. Waddington proposed the epigenetic landscape to explain how genetically identical cells differentiate into distinct tissues, picturing cells as balls rolling down channeled valleys into fate attractors. Modern experimental techniques like single-cell RNA sequencing and mathematical dynamical systems modeling are now translating this visual metaphor into rigorous mathematical topology. Crucially, the landscape proves not to be static: it shifts dynamically as cells interact and exert feedback on one another. Viewing cell differentiation through this lens provides practical blueprints for regenerative medicine and suggests novel oncology therapies that treat cancer as an attractor basin out of which cells might be guided.
It bridges historical ideas in biology with cutting-edge complexity theory and single-cell genomics, offering a systems-level counterweight to simplistic, gene-centric models of development.
fit 8 · substance 7 · originality 5 · importance 6 · writing 8
- 2Science & nature6.2
Triplet of ‘Ghostly’ Galaxies Hints at What Dark Matter Is — and Isn’t
A collision may have left these galaxies without dark matter. That spells trouble for alternative gravity theories.
Why it's here
A lucid science dispatch explaining how three rare, dark-matter-deficient galaxies provide compelling evidence that dark matter is a physical substance rather than an artifact of modified gravity.
Astronomers analyzing the diffuse galaxies DF2, DF4, and DF9 have discovered that all three contain almost no dark matter, leaving only ordinary matter to hold their sparse stars together. A recent study models these formations as the aftermath of an ancient galactic smash-up, in which collisionless dark matter sailed past while ordinary gas collided and separated. This physical decoupling provides a strong argument against modified Newtonian dynamics (MOND), as matter can be stripped away during collisions while universal laws of gravity cannot simply switch off in selected galaxies.
It offers an accessible, well-grounded look at cutting-edge astrophysics and the ongoing empirical debate between dark matter models and modified gravity theories.
fit 7 · substance 6 · originality 5 · importance 6 · writing 7
- 3Science & nature5.6
Three Indie Science Project Ideas
People often have a sense that all the low-hanging scientific fruit has been picked, or that all the fruit that’s left can only be picked by huge teams with lots of funding. But in fact, there are still lots of projects that are just the right scale for Indie Science.
Why it's here
A fun, breezy brainstorm of neglected empirical questions that small-scale or citizen scientists could realistically tackle.
Mainstream research often overlooks cheap, high-variance questions due to low prestige or funding misalignments. The authors outline three concrete projects ripe for independent investigation: testing creatine supplementation for relieving menstrual symptoms, auditing the dubious historical evidence behind official nutritional guidelines like potassium and iodine, and running controlled food-swapping trials to investigate anecdotal claims about American versus European food sensitivities. Each proposal sketches practical experimental protocols, from crossover RCTs to factorial dietary reintroduction tests.
Readers interested in progress studies, the sociology of science, and novel empirical design will appreciate this grounded perspective on low-hanging scientific fruit outside institutional academia.
fit 6 · substance 5 · originality 6 · importance 5 · writing 6
Economics & society
- 1Economics & society6.4
Barbara Ward’s vision
In 1957, the economist and journalist Barbara Ward gave the first of the Aggrey-Fraser-Guggisberg Memorial Lectures at the University College of Ghana. Shortly after Kwame Nkrumah led the British colony of the Gold Coast towards self-government, he invited Ward to address the independent country’s first cohort of…
Why it's here
A thoughtful intellectual portrait tracing how a mid-century modernization theorist evolved into a founding architect of sustainable development.
The essay traces the intellectual trajectory of Barbara Ward, an influential 20th-century economist, advisor, and public intellectual. It outlines her progression from a post-war modernization theorist who believed Christian universalism and Western financial assistance could lift postcolonial nations out of poverty, to a pioneer of environmental politics. By analyzing her key texts—including her formulation of the 'Spaceship Earth' metaphor and her preparatory work for the 1972 UN Stockholm Conference—the text shows how Ward attempted to reconcile the Global South's need for economic growth with global ecological limits.
It offers an engaging piece of intellectual history that clarifies the roots of contemporary debates over sustainable development, planetary boundaries, and postcolonial equity.
fit 7 · substance 6 · originality 6 · importance 6 · writing 7
- 2Economics & society5.8
Stop spending money on smaller classes
I’m a little late to this story, but New York Times columnist Nikole Hannah-Jones wrote a very complex and interesting post about sending her daughter to a crappy New York City public school. She was motivated by egalitarian impulses, but it turned out to be bad for her daughter, and later she felt guilty about making…
Why it's here
A brisk, data-driven critique of class-size reduction mandates that effectively synthesizes recent empirical literature.
Noah Smith challenges the common assumption that shrinking public school class sizes is an effective way to improve educational outcomes. Reviewing recent meta-analyses and updated econometric studies, he shows that the gains from famous early pilot programs fail to replicate at statewide scales. The push for smaller classes forces districts to expand headcount from a diluted applicant pool, whereas school budgets would be better deployed raising salaries to attract and retain higher-quality teachers.
It offers a clean, empirical look at a perennial public policy dilemma, grounded in labor economics and replication research.
fit 6 · substance 6 · originality 5 · importance 6 · writing 6
- 3Economics & society5.6
A Nobel for New Keynesian macro, at last!
I have a Google Doc with a long list of posts I’ve been meaning to write. Far down the list was a line that read “New Keynesian macroeconomics deserves a Nobel”. Somehow I never got around to writing that post, and now I never will. Because today, it happened! This year’s Econ Nobel went to Bob Hall and Mike Woodford,…
Why it's here
A clear, accessible primer on the evolution of New Keynesian macroeconomics and central banking, though it largely covers standard textbook history.
Following the breakdown of early Keynesian aggregate models in the 1970s, macroeconomists turned to microfoundations and rational expectations to build policy-invariant theories. Bob Hall demonstrated that consumption behaves like a random walk when consumers plan forward, while later theorists explored price and wage stickiness to explain monetary policy's real effects. Michael Woodford synthesized these elements into the workhorse New Keynesian model used by central banks, which later adapted to include zero-lower-bound dynamics, forward guidance, and fiscal stimulus. The essay argues that the relatively painless post-pandemic disinflation serves as a real-world validation of Woodford and Hall's forward-looking framework.
It offers an engaging, intuitive history of economic thought detailing how modern central banking models married rational expectations with real-world price frictions.
fit 6 · substance 6 · originality 4 · importance 5 · writing 7
Other
- 1Other5.8
Maybe the Rapture is already here
Back when I was a teenager, a lot of people were very into the Left Behind series. Evangelical Christianity was still very strong in those days, especially in Texas, and Left Behind blew up by putting Christian eschatology into page-turning airport-bookstore-novel form. People really believed that the stories in those…
Why it's here
A lively, provocative cultural essay that connects the rise of passive short-form video to demographic collapse and the Fermi Paradox, though it operates more on intuitive leaps than rigorous proof.
Shared public culture has collapsed twice over, moving from the broadcast era of mass media to the participatory hive mind of meme culture, and now into the hyper-fragmented, passive world of vertical short-form video. These algorithmic video feeds isolate users in personalized bubbles, degrading long-term planning and reducing real-life human connection. Drawing on recent empirical studies linking smartphone and mobile broadband adoption to falling birth rates, the piece suggests that this inward digital retreat may function as a Great Filter. Sentient species may simply wirehead their dopamine pathways into demographic extinction rather than building starfaring civilizations.
It blends cultural criticism, demographic trends, and speculative tech philosophy into an evocative meditation on how modern media formats rewire human interaction.
fit 7 · substance 5 · originality 5 · importance 5 · writing 7