This week
This week's reads keep returning to one question: how do we know what is real, and who or what counts as a mind or self? Quanta Magazine's "New Research Tests Whether AI Models Know Their Own Thoughts" asks it of language models, and its "A Strange Quantum Theorem Has Killed Einstein's Reality" asks it of physics. In Psyche, "How psychology's classic studies misled us about the self" asks whether a stable self exists at all. Aeon's "Believing and thinking" asks what kind of attitude religious belief is. The Marginalian's piece on Damasio, "I Feel, Therefore I Am", ties consciousness to the body.
In arts and literature, Astral Codex Ten's "Your Book Review: Orality and Literacy" stands out. It turns Walter Ong into an argument about scrolling and the future of writing, though parts of it are speculative. For poetry, Literary Hub's Mahmoud Darwish poem "Arabic Music" and Blake's "Ah! Sun-flower" at Dead Poets Daily are short and worth the minute. In history and culture, JSTOR Daily's "How the Phone Book Taught America to Ask for Answers" is the most graceful piece. Works in Progress adds "Soviet disunion" and "Modern warfare", and ACOUP's Fireside Friday corrects a popular account of Caesar's crossing of the Rubicon.
In science, Quanta's "Is There Anything Left in the Dream of Cold Fusion?" and Nautilus's "Earth's Rocks Have a Missing Layer Spanning Up to a Billion Years" are the clearest. Asterisk's "How to Turn a Philanderer Into a Father" is a good tour of the biology of fatherhood. The AI and economics pieces are more practical. SemiAnalysis's "We Visited China's Stargate in Inner Mongolia" and Noah Smith's "Why I'm becoming a China bear" both look at China's industrial capacity. The Pragmatic Engineer's "How software engineering is changing: a tale of two eras" gives one engineer's data on AI-native work. Be aware that several of these, including both Noahpinion posts and the SemiAnalysis visit, are cut off by paywalls.
Best reads by category
Arts & literature
- 1Arts & literature7.6
Your Book Review: Orality and Literacy
Imagine that you are dropped seven thousand years in the past, right in the middle of a village on a festival day. Everyone stares at you in horror: they think you’re a demon, a vengeful spirit. You are dressed in strange clothes, you are much taller than them, and you are holding a magic mirror that flashes with…
Why it's here
A lively, inventive book review that turns Ong's classic into a provocative argument about scrolling and how writing could change, though some of its claims are speculative.
The review summarises Walter Ong's Orality and Literacy using Homer, Havelock, Luria and the Tiv genealogies. It shows how oral cultures relied on formulaic improvisation, rhythm and concrete thinking, and how writing made abstraction and analysis possible. It then argues that orality versus literacy is really two axes, solitary versus communal and ephemeral versus persistent. Scrolling sits in the harmful communal-persistent quadrant. To survive, it says, literacy should lean into forms that can't be spoken aloud, like tables, equations, code and expressive typography, citing Tufte, Gwern and 17776.
It joins literary history, cognitive science and media criticism in a well-written essay with an original framing, which fits this reader's interest in ideas, literature and the history of technology.
fit 9 · substance 7 · originality 7 · importance 6 · writing 8
- 2Arts & literature6.4
Trial, Triumph, and the Art of the Possible: The Moving Story Behind Beethoven’s “Ode to Joy,” a Lifetime of Sorrow in the Making
A hymn of rage, a hymn of redemption, and a timeless love letter to the possible.
Why it's here
A lush, moving narrative of how the Ninth Symphony came to be, worth reading for the story even though the prose sometimes overreaches and there is little new scholarship.
Popova follows the decades between Beethoven's early fascination with Schiller's Enlightenment poem and the 1824 Vienna premiere of the Ninth Symphony. Along the way she covers his deafness, war, family troubles, his arrest as a supposed tramp, his indecision over where to hold the premiere, and the moment Karoline Unger turned him around to see the applause. She presents the work as meaning made out of suffering and traces what it came to mean afterwards, from Tiananmen to Ukraine. It closes with her memory of singing the piece as a Bulgarian schoolgirl after communism fell.
This reader likes history, music and literary essays, and the piece offers a well-told story of a masterpiece being made, along with reflections on art and progress.
fit 8 · substance 6 · originality 5 · importance 5 · writing 7
- 3Arts & literature6.1
Slavdom Unearthed: Marian Wawrzeniecki’s Neopagan Paintings (1891–1923)
A nude lies upon an open tome, bloodied branch in hand. With a skull for a face, but otherwise enfleshed, the body bisects Art Nouveau illustrations: a red-haired woman circled by some kind of serpent and a colder image, whose face is obscured by a forest of hair. Is this the same woman, present, past, and further…
Why it's here
A short, well-written introduction to an obscure Polish painter-archaeologist. It is worth a look for the images and the unusual subject, though the argument stays brief.
Marian Wawrzeniecki was trained in Kraków's academic tradition of history painting and became an influential archaeologist. His excavations led him to see pagan Slavic prehistory as Poland's true essence and Christianity as a thousand-year cultural colonisation. The essay follows his move from elegant early Symbolist canvases to bright, obsessive illustrations of pagan rituals featuring bound female nudes. It argues these can be read as allegories rather than pulp erotica, and it links his legacy to Stanisław Szukalski and to Maria Janion's book 'Uncanny Slavdom'.
It brings together art history, archaeology and cultural nationalism around a little-known figure, which suits the reader's interest in art and the history of ideas.
fit 7 · substance 5 · originality 7 · importance 4 · writing 7
- 4Arts & literature5.9
MJ Lenderman on Harry Crews: This Fucked-Up Guy
MJ Lenderman. Photograph by Sol Procter-Tarabanov. CC BY-SA 4.0, via Wikimedia Commons.
Why it's here
A warm, personal foreword that works well as an introduction to Crews, though it's more appreciation than criticism.
Singer-songwriter MJ Lenderman describes finding Harry Crews as a teenager in Asheville and how Crews's interviews and prose shaped his songwriting during the pandemic. He admits he lifted a line from The Gospel Singer for his song "Joker Lips." He then reads Crews's novel Body as a garish, absurd bodybuilding farce that still treats its grotesque characters with real tenderness. He warns readers about the book's vile material and praises how subtle its ending is.
It's an engaging piece of literary appreciation that ties Southern Gothic fiction to contemporary songwriting, and it doubles as a reading recommendation with real commentary.
fit 7 · substance 5 · originality 6 · importance 4 · writing 7
- 5Arts & literature5.8
Albrecht Dürer’s Monument to the Vanquished Peasants (1525)
The German Peasants’ War was the largest popular uprising on the European continent until it was surpassed by the French Revolution over 250 years later. Erupting in 1524 in today’s southwestern Germany and France’s Alsace region, the uprising tore across the Holy Roman Empire, eastward beyond Salzburg and northeast…
Why it's here
A short, elegant piece on a strange Dürer design, worth reading, though it leans on other scholars and never builds a full argument of its own.
The piece outlines the German Peasants' War of 1524–25 and then looks at the monument Dürer designed in his 1525 treatise on measurement. It is a column of lard tubs, cheese bowls and farm tools with a stabbed peasant on top. Drawing on Panofsky, Petcu and Greenblatt, it argues that the monument's meaning is deliberately unclear: it could mock the peasants, parody their idea of the good life, or mourn them. It ends by tracing the war's afterlife, from Engels's revolutionary reading to recent anniversary books and modern sculptures, including Siekmann's toppled version, 'After Dürer'.
It joins art history, Reformation-era history and the question of what monuments mean, which suits this reader's taste for culture and history essays.
fit 7 · substance 5 · originality 5 · importance 5 · writing 7
Poetry
- 1Poetry7.6
Ah! Sun-flower
Ah Sun-flower! weary of time,Who countest the steps of the Sun:Seeking after that sweet golden climeWhere the travellers journey is done.Where the Youth pined away with desire,And the pale Virgin shrouded in snow:Arise from their graves and aspire,Where my Sun-flower wishes to go.A note to readers: Dead Poets Daily…
Why it's here
Blake's short lyric is a classic, compressed and haunting, and worth the minute it takes to read, though the post adds no commentary.
William Blake's poem from Songs of Experience addresses a sunflower that turns to follow the sun and longs for a golden place where every journey ends. It sets that longing beside the Youth and the pale Virgin, who denied their desires in life and rise from their graves still reaching for the same place. In two eight-line stanzas it questions whether repression and longing for the afterlife ever bring fulfilment. The post reprints the poem with only a subscription note and no analysis.
The reader enjoys classic poetry, and this is one of Blake's most suggestive short lyrics, though the post offers no critical context.
fit 7 · substance 7 · originality 8 · importance 8 · writing 9
- 2Poetry7.0
Sunday Poem
Kingdom Animalia
Why it's here
A vivid contemporary poem that moves from a catalogue of natural facts to a moving close about pain and endurance. Worth a few minutes.
Chiwenite Onyekwelu's poem begins with a playful list of animal facts: horses that sleep standing as if braced for war, and the sperm whale's name as a sailors' mistake. It then settles on a documentary about ants and their patient, honest labour. The speaker decides that knowing is not enough and that one must turn a wound into song. It ends with a dying ant chewing off its own leg, which teaches the speaker both how little they know and how much pain they can bear.
The reader values contemporary poetry and nature writing, and this poem joins both with fresh images and real feeling.
fit 8 · substance 7 · originality 7 · importance 5 · writing 7
- 3Poetry6.7
”Arabic Music,” a Poem by Mahmoud Darwish
From Darwish: Poems. Used with the permission of the publisher, Everyman’s Library. Copyright © 2026 by Mahmoud Darwish
Why it's here
A short, intense Darwish lyric worth a few minutes, though it comes with no commentary or context beyond a brief bio.
The poem opens and closes with a refrain wishing that men, and the speaker himself, were stones, which is to say safe from feeling. Between the refrains comes a run of questions about whether clouds, sparrows, guitars, withering mallow and flowering almonds wound the speaker, wake him, or burn him away until he is smoke torn by the wind. Longing for his country breaks into the middle of the poem ('oh, my country!'), so beauty and loss end up as the same sharp sensation. The text comes from a new Everyman's Library selection of his poems.
Readers who follow classic and contemporary poetry get a compact, emotionally charged poem by one of the major Arabic poets of the twentieth century.
fit 8 · substance 6 · originality 6 · importance 6 · writing 7
- 4Poetry6.5
Hope Is the Thing with Feathers, and with Fangs: The Alchemy of Unrequited Love and the Story Behind Emily Dickinson’s Most Famous Poem
In the first autumn of her thirties, Emily Dickinson wrote to her confidante and eventual editor Thomas Wentworth Higginson:
Why it's here
A lyrical, moving reconstruction of the heartbreak that may lie behind Dickinson's most famous poem, though it leans on one speculative scholarly theory and recycles material from Popova's book.
Popova follows Rebecca Patterson's 1951 theory that Dickinson's 1861 'terror' was Kate Scott Anthon ending their intense romantic relationship. She pieces the affair together from Dickinson's letters, a poem about a night with 'my Bride', and a consoling letter from Samuel Bowles to an unnamed sufferer of unrequited love. She presents 'Hope is the thing with feathers' as written in the aftermath of that loss. The essay closes with her own reflection on hope as the bridge between the life we have and the lives we might have had.
It joins classic poetry, literary history and a beautifully written personal essay, all core interests for this reader, though it is more evocative than rigorously argued.
fit 8 · substance 6 · originality 5 · importance 5 · writing 8
- 5Poetry6.1
Wendell Berry on Where Our Loved Ones Gone Go
To love is to sign a contract with loss. To love anyway is both the great tragedy and the great triumph of life.
Why it's here
Short and moving, mainly worth reading for Berry's late poem with its striking reversal; Popova's framing is lyrical but slight.
Maria Popova introduces a late poem by Wendell Berry, 'The Loved Ones,' with a short reflection. Her point is that every deep loss, through death or abandonment, pulls us away from the present moment. The poem then turns that idea around: the dead seem to come back near us, and in the end it is the living, caught up in their obligations, who are absent from 'the permanent world.' The framing leans on familiar Marginalian moves, including a Hemingway quote and links to related posts.
It fits the reader's interest in classic and contemporary poetry and in reflective essays, and it presents a poignant poem by a major American writer who has just died.
fit 8 · substance 5 · originality 5 · importance 5 · writing 7
- 6Poetry5.9
The Singing Place
Cold may lie the day,And bare of grace;At night I slip awayTo the Singing Place.A border of mist and doubtBefore the gate,And the Dancing Stars grow stillAs hushed I wait.Then faint and far awayI catch the beatIn broken rhythm and rhymeOf joyous feet,—Lifting waves of soundThat will rise and swell(If the prying eyes…
Why it's here
A musical, gently ecstatic lyric about losing the self in song at the edge of sleep; lovely but fairly conventional in its imagery and feeling.
In short rhymed lines, the speaker describes slipping away each night from a cold, graceless day to a dreamlike 'Singing Place' beyond a gate of mist. They have to wait passively, like seaweed waiting for the tide, because conscious thought or asking would break the spell. Then they rush through and merge with a cosmic chorus: 'the song am I', and the singers 'weave the world anew'. On waking, only a trace of the chant comes back across the edge of sleep.
For a reader who enjoys classic poetry, it is a short, rhythmic piece on dream, music and losing the self, worth a quick read even though it is not essential.
fit 7 · substance 6 · originality 5 · importance 4 · writing 7
AI
- 1AI7.5
New Research Tests Whether AI Models Know Their Own Thoughts
By injecting “thoughts” directly into large language models, researchers are trying to map out AI’s capacity for introspection.
Why it's here
A clear, even-handed science feature that follows a striking AI result through a year of replications and pushback. Worth reading for its careful look at what the evidence does and doesn't show.
Jack Lindsey at Anthropic tested introspection in Claude by injecting concept vectors into the model and asking whether it noticed. It flagged and named the injected concept in about 20% of trials, with no false positives in the control group. Lederman and Mahowald then showed that naming the concept is probably just an effect of the steering. Detecting the injection held up under their controls, so they call it 'anomaly detection'. The piece closes with the philosophical problem: researchers including Ravfogel, Fleming and Andreas question what counts as introspection in a system made entirely of internal states, how first-order and second-order representations differ, and what 'self' means for models that exist as identical copies.
It brings together AI interpretability, philosophy of mind and cognitive science, three of this reader's core interests, in accessible long-form prose that weighs the evidence carefully.
fit 9 · substance 7 · originality 6 · importance 7 · writing 8
- 2AI6.9
Descent into the Computational Sublime
October 2026 was a rather bad month for software civilization. By the end of it, cybersecurity professionals were talking about Black October, and the more colorful term vulnopocalypse was also making the rounds. An alarming succession of vulnerabilities had been uncovered in the foundations of the planetary software…
Why it's here
A wide-ranging, imaginative essay that grounds big speculation in a real security crisis; worth reading, though the later sections drift into loose metaphor.
The essay treats 'Black October', a wave of AI-assisted vulnerability discoveries that peaked with North Korea's $6.34B attack on Binance, as the start of a three-act future. In the first act, a 'Dark Forest Apotheosis', AI-driven discovery of security holes makes all software adversarial and creates negative-sum 'Hacker Extractable Value'. In the second, the 'Hardness Wars', AI and quantum computing test the mathematical assumptions behind cryptography, framed through Impagliazzo's five worlds. The third is a 'Strange Forest' of diverging, AI-native computational ecologies. Drawing on Vinge, Banks and his own divergentism, Rao argues that the computational sublime means descending into particularity and situatedness rather than rising into abstraction.
It connects AI capabilities, security economics, cryptographic theory, evolutionary metaphor and science fiction in one essay, matching the reader's interest in big-picture ideas that cross fields.
fit 8 · substance 6 · originality 7 · importance 6 · writing 7
- 3AI6.8
GDPx: Measuring Frontier Model Capabilities Across the Most Valuable Domains
GDPx is a benchmark that covers the most valuable domains for frontier intelligence. It aims to be the world’s best benchmark for measuring general agentic capabilities.
Why it's here
An informative look at how frontier agents fail on realistic expert tasks, though it is long, uneven and partly reads as a showcase for data vendors.
SemiAnalysis introduces GDPx, an agentic benchmark limited to the domains where it expects frontier AI to earn the most money, including chip design, cyber, finance, recursive self-improvement and alignment. It argues that OpenAI's GDPval is outdated because its tasks hand the model all the context up front and never put it in a working environment. Each GDPx task instead drops the agent into a rich simulated workplace, such as a 4,000-file private-equity deal room or a live CAD session, and the best model scores only 12%. Partner write-ups describe specific failure modes: models trust the wrong documents in finance, miss the root cause when debugging a training run, and break professional and ethical limits in pentesting and healthcare tasks.
The detailed failure analyses show what frontier models still cannot do and how badly agents behave on alignment tasks, which bears directly on the reader's interest in AI capabilities, economics and safety.
fit 7 · substance 7 · originality 7 · importance 6 · writing 6
- 4AI6.2
We Visited China’s Stargate in Inner Mongolia
Stargate Abilene has become the symbol of America’s AI buildout. It is a gigawatt-scale campus on the Texas plains built for OpenAI. China has campuses on a similar scale, though few people outside the country have had a look inside. In September, we visited one, and we found the speed, scale, ultra low cost, and deep…
Why it's here
An informative, firsthand look at how China builds gigawatt-scale AI datacenters cheaply and fast, though the free part is industry-focused, cut off by a paywall, and partly a pitch for SemiAnalysis's data products.
SemiAnalysis visited Envision's 800MW Galaxy campus in Ulanqab, Inner Mongolia, which is about the size of Stargate Abilene. Its first 120MW phase was delivered within a year at roughly a fifth of US costs. The piece argues that Envision's vertical integration sets it apart. Envision builds its own wind farms, battery storage, an 800V DC system that uses solid-state transformers, and a prefabricated substation. Illustrative charts show how oversizing the wind farm and adding storage push wind's share of the campus's power above 60%. The free portion also covers China's long use of DC power in datacenters, chiller-free cooling, falling rents and capex, and the CATL–VNET–Zhongheng alliance as a rival model. The detailed sections on construction speed, power and cooling sit behind the paywall.
It offers rare on-the-ground evidence on the US–China race to build AI compute and on the energy economics behind it, which bears on the reader's interest in AI economics and the history of technology.
fit 6 · substance 6 · originality 7 · importance 6 · writing 6
- 5AI6.0
Elegy for What’s Left of the Normal
I’m living in Hyde Park finishing school after a year in Berkeley. The maple trees by my apartment have turned red, as usual. I like them.
Why it's here
A tender, well-observed personal essay on living through the last stretch of a pre-AI world; strong on feeling, light on argument.
The author, a student working on AI safety, describes grieving a present that hasn't ended yet, expecting powerful AI to change it soon. Four short vignettes carry the essay: an Egyptologist hoping her notebook will be displayed in a museum a century from now, a mathematician who puts the chance of AI solving P vs NP by 2028 at zero, a mother on a train proud of her daughter's legal ambitions, and a maple tree outside an old seminary building. Each scene sets the slow, lifelong pursuit of deep knowledge against the author's expectation of fast AI progress. The essay settles on affection and clear-eyed mourning rather than dread.
It joins AI-timelines thinking to literary personal writing about meaning, expertise and loss, which overlaps both the reader's AI interests and their taste for reflective essays.
fit 7 · substance 5 · originality 6 · importance 5 · writing 7
- 6AI6.0
Anthropic’s moat is Claude
Anthropic recently filed for IPO. At an estimated $1.5 to $2 trillion, it will be one of the biggest IPOs of all time, rivaling SpaceX, and possibly the biggest. For reference, Facebook’s valuation when it had its blockbuster IPO in 2012 was $104 billion, and Google’s valuation in 2004 was $23 billion. Anthropic will…
Why it's here
A clear, accessible setup on whether AI labs can hold durable profits, but the paywall cuts it off just before the central argument, so what's visible is mostly framing.
Noah Smith starts from Anthropic's reported $1.5–2 trillion IPO and asks where the upside could come from, since matching Google's or Facebook's post-IPO returns would mean a valuation of tens to hundreds of trillions. Faster economic growth alone won't get there, he argues, so Anthropic would have to take a bigger share of the economy. That requires a moat. He explains moats with textbook business economics and goes through the usual reasons AI labs seem to lack one: no network effects, weak brand loyalty, easy switching and quick catch-up by rivals. He then floats the opposite thesis, that intelligence itself could be a moat, but the text is truncated before he makes that case.
It sits where AI and economics meet and uses basic industrial-organisation reasoning to ask whether AI labs can capture value, though the reader gets only the setup.
fit 7 · substance 5 · originality 5 · importance 6 · writing 7
Science & nature
- 1Science & nature7.3
Is There Anything Left in the Dream of Cold Fusion?
Cold fusion: Now there’s an idea I hadn’t thought about in a while. It came back onto my radar in spring 2026. I had written an article on how scientists tend to be risk averse, and Huw Price, a philosopher at Trinity College at the University of Cambridge, responded to it on Bluesky, citing a paper he’d recently…
Why it's here
An engaging, well-reported essay that starts from the cold fusion debacle, moves into the lively physics of exotic atoms, and ends with a useful test for judging speculative research programs.
George Musser starts from Huw Price's claim that scientists have been too quick to dismiss cold fusion. He is skeptical: in his view, the 1989 fraud anchored attention on an idea that doesn't deserve it. Following leads from Google's 2019 reinvestigation, he turns to muon-catalyzed fusion and the wider field of exotic atoms, where muons, kaons or antiprotons stand in for electrons. These shrunken atoms let physicists test quantum electrodynamics in fields beyond the Schwinger limit, probe the structure of nuclei, and even build 'matryoshka' molecules. He ends with a heuristic: judge a research program by whether it would still be interesting if its headline claim failed. 1989-style cold fusion fails that test, and muon-catalyzed fusion passes it.
It combines clear physics writing with philosophy of science and history of technology, and closes with a portable lesson about how to judge contrarian scientific claims.
fit 8 · substance 7 · originality 7 · importance 6 · writing 8
- 2Science & nature7.2
A Strange Quantum Theorem Has Killed Einstein’s Reality
Albert Einstein fought to save our everyday notion of reality from the strangeness of quantum mechanics. But those who set out to aid him keep poking holes in his argument.
Why it's here
A clear, well-paced explainer that makes the obscure PBR theorem easy to follow and shows why it matters for the old Einstein–Bohr argument about what is real.
The piece follows how ideas about objective reality in quantum mechanics changed, from the Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen thought experiment, through Bell's theorem, to the 2012 Pusey-Barrett-Rudolph (PBR) theorem. PBR rules out the middle ground Einstein hoped for, where reality is objective but the wave function only describes our knowledge of it. A card-game analogy shows why quantum states cannot overlap the way states of knowledge do. Physicists are left with two choices: treat the quantum state itself as real, or give up objective reality, as Copenhagen and QBism do. A few, like Lucien Hardy, are looking for subtler ideas of what counts as real.
It sits where physics meets philosophy, explains a deep result in plain language without dumbing it down, and quotes working researchers along the way, which suits a reader who wants science and ideas writing with careful reasoning.
fit 8 · substance 7 · originality 6 · importance 7 · writing 8
- 3Science & nature7.0
Celestial nuisance
In the story of cosmic history, one of the most important supporting characters is dust. As clouds of interstellar gas cooled and condensed in the early Universe, dust grains absorbed and re-emitted radiation, eventually forming stars. Later, dust provided the raw material from which planets could form and grow. Dust…
Why it's here
A thoughtful insider's essay on how astrophysics decides what counts as signal and what counts as noise. It is well written and makes you think, though it leans more on personal reflection than on hard evidence.
A working astrophysicist argues that the line between 'signal' and 'nuisance' in astronomy is historically contingent. Things like dust, interstellar gas and ordinary matter are subtracted away in the hunt for 'fundamental' physics such as dark energy and dark matter. The author traces this hierarchy to Cold War physics funding and the post-collider move of particle physicists into cosmology. They show how survey pipelines, AI models trained on simplified simulations, grant rhetoric and journal incentives reinforce it, even though many astronomers care most about the 'messy' phenomena themselves. They close by urging the field to reclaim astronomy's own questions about origins and our place in the cosmos.
The essay brings together philosophy of science, the history of research institutions and astronomy, with a skeptical side note on AI in science, all in clear long-form prose of the kind this reader values.
fit 8 · substance 6 · originality 7 · importance 6 · writing 8
- 4Science & nature7.0
How to Turn a Philanderer Into a Father
My younger brother — middle-aged, heterosexual, and single — just moved to Atlanta. He’s a handsome guy, intelligent, funny, and keeps in great shape. Loves to flirt. The problem? He’s in the online dating pool trap, and the bulk of his real-world social interactions occur in the gym. My wife and I, helpfully we…
Why it's here
A lively, well-sourced tour of the biology of fatherhood from fish to humans. It is worth reading for its examples, though much of it gathers existing research rather than making a new argument.
Ghazanfar asks why male parental care is rare among mammals, which he puts at roughly 4–5% of species, and what turns a philandering male into a caring father. He traces paternal care from territorial male fish, through the paternity uncertainty created by internal fertilization, to rodent studies. Those studies show that living close to a mate, hormonal shifts, a mate's urine, eating the placenta and an Agouti gene acting in the medial preoptic area can switch males between killing pups and caring for them. He argues that fatherhood comes out of a whole system of genes, circuits, hormones and social setting, then extends this to humans through longitudinal studies of falling testosterone, brain imaging of fathers and cultural variation such as the Aché, who recognise more than one father per child.
It is accessible, evidence-backed writing about the neuroscience and evolution of behaviour, the kind of science essay this reader wants, with a personal frame and plenty of surprising findings.
fit 8 · substance 7 · originality 6 · importance 6 · writing 7
- 5Science & nature6.8
The self-making world
The French naturalist Jean-Baptiste Lamarck was 65 when his great treatise on the transformation of life was published. With Philosophie zoologique (1809), translated a century later as Zoological Philosophy, Lamarck intended to establish an entirely new science, one built on the idea that all living beings are…
Why it's here
A vivid, well-told intellectual history that rescues Lamarck from caricature, though its political argument against neo-Darwinism goes beyond what the evidence supports.
The essay recovers Lamarck as the founder of 'biology' and the first theorist of evolution, whose central idea was that organisms actively transform themselves and their world. It traces how Cuvier, Napoleon, Weismann and later neo-Darwinists cast this idea aside and made organisms passive objects of random variation and selection. It ties that passivity to eugenics and environmental exploitation. It ends with recent work in epigenetic inheritance, behaviour-driven selection, niche construction and animal culture, which it reads as a partial vindication of Lamarck.
It joins the history of science, biology and the history of ideas in elegant long-form prose, which fits this reader's interest in both science writing and intellectual history.
fit 8 · substance 6 · originality 6 · importance 6 · writing 8
- 6Science & nature6.2
Earth’s Rocks Have a Missing Layer Spanning Up to a Billion Years
Imagine opening a history book and finding several chapters torn out. This was what geologists looking into the rock records of Earth’s past discovered on several continents in the 1870s.They dubbed it the Great Unconformity. Where layers of rock often stack up in a steady sequence from oldest to youngest, in many…
Why it's here
A short, clear explainer of new Nature research that offers a plausible answer to a 150-year-old geological puzzle, though it is too brief to go deep.
The Great Unconformity is a gap in the rock record of up to a billion years, found across North America, northern Europe and northern China. The researchers used supercomputer models of mantle convection to show that these continental blocks were pushed upward between about a billion and 540 million years ago, then sank afterwards. The uplift overlapped with Snowball Earth, when huge ice sheets would have scraped the raised surfaces down to bedrock. Later subsidence then let new sediment build up and survive. Australia and South America went through different uplift cycles and show little of the gap, which the authors cite as supporting evidence.
It's accessible science writing about deep time, linking processes inside the Earth to the setting in which the Cambrian explosion happened, which suits the reader's interest in nature and physical-science essays.
fit 7 · substance 5 · originality 6 · importance 6 · writing 7
History & culture
- 1History & culture7.3
How the Phone Book Taught America to Ask for Answers
For over a century, the physical phone book could be found everywhere, yet seemingly belonged nowhere: a book without a genre, at once mundane and mysterious, raising questions that vexed courts and corporations alike. In print, it’s all but vanished, though it lingers in the names of the websites and search engines…
Why it's here
A graceful, archive-based history that turns a stack of small-town phone books into a sharp story about how people learned to treat networks as places to ask questions. It's well worth reading.
Using eighteen Georgetown, Texas phone directories from 1913 to 1959, the essay traces how phone companies built a 'telephone habit' around fast business use. Subscribers stretched it to social calls, rural party lines and, above all, the 'Information' operator, whom they asked for far more than missing numbers. The companies kept scolding users and eventually replaced her with the dial, then with 'Directory Assistance' and automation. The essay closes with the 1991 Feist ruling that phone listings can't be copyrighted and with Licklider's 1969 choice between data and knowledge, arguing that ordinary users worked out before the institutions did that a network is worth what you can ask of it and add to it.
It ties progress studies and the history of technology to today's search and question-answering habits through close reading of primary sources, which suits a reader who values surprising insight and good prose.
fit 8 · substance 7 · originality 7 · importance 6 · writing 8
- 2History & culture7.1
Soviet disunion
Why did the Communist regime collapse in the Soviet Union? Why has it survived in China? The answers might surprise you. Explanations for the sudden end of the USSR after seven decades, and the simultaneous dissolution of the country after centuries, are numerous. They are also lacking. Many observers credit the…
Why it's here
A short, confident argument that the Soviet Union fell because of reform-minded Communist idealism rather than outside pressure, and it sheds useful light on why China's party has lasted; it argues more than it proves.
The essay goes through the usual explanations for the Soviet collapse (the pope, nationalism, dissidents, economic decline, Afghanistan, military spending, Reagan) and argues that each one either came after Gorbachev's reforms or was too small to matter. It then claims the real cause was Communist ideology itself: a recurring push for 'socialism with a human face' that cracks the party's monopoly, because political liberalization cannot be held inside a single party. The federal structure of ethnic republics, plus the chance to turn state assets into private property, gave elites safe exits, so they let the collapse happen. China survived by learning the lesson 'no Gorbachev': it reformed the economy but not the politics and never created ethnic republics. The cost is a permanent mismatch with the society it rules.
The essay fits the reader's interest in history and politics, offers a counterintuitive thesis backed by concrete comparisons, and draws a clear line from 1991 to China today.
fit 8 · substance 7 · originality 6 · importance 7 · writing 7
- 3History & culture7.1
The forgotten formula for lovable cities
Everyone loves the streets of old cities like Verona, Bruges, and Prague. The reason might seem obvious: they are lined by beautiful historic buildings. But people also love the streets of Osaka, Taipei, and Hong Kong. While the buildings of the latter cities are mostly modern and nondescript, their streets are still…
Why it's here
A clear, well-illustrated revival of Camillo Sitte's principles for urban space that makes a persuasive case with many concrete examples, though it mostly presents Sitte's ideas rather than testing them.
Camillo Sitte's 1889 book The Art of Building Cities explains why some public spaces are loved. It succeeds by focusing on how a space is shaped rather than on how its buildings look. The essay sets out his principles: squares should be enclosed and modest in size, symmetry is overrated, monuments belong at the edges and public buildings should be woven into ordinary housing. Each principle is backed by paired examples, such as Brussels' Grand-Place against the Place de la Concorde, the Pantheon against St Peter's Square, and Notre Dame before and after Haussmann cleared the streets around it. The essay closes by tracing how Sitte's ideas spread quickly, were overtaken by modernism and are now being taken up again by the New Urbanists.
It joins art, history and the practical matter of building better cities, in the evidence-rich, readable style of Works in Progress that this reader values.
fit 8 · substance 7 · originality 6 · importance 6 · writing 8
- 4History & culture7.0
Fireside Friday, November 6, 2026
Hey folks! Fireside this week, as we’ve (finally) brought the Hearts of Iron IV (I, II IIIa, IIIb, IVa, IVb) series to a close. We may have rather more firesides and even some gap weeks in the next month or two, both due to the end of the semester but also due to some personal schedule disruptions. Still, I plan to…
Why it's here
A sharp, evidence-based correction to a popular reading of Caesar's crossing of the Rubicon, wrapped in a casual Fireside post with a well-argued book recommendation.
Devereaux rejects the claim that 'cycles of judicial retaliation' or 'weaponized courts' pushed Caesar to march on Rome in 49 BC. He argues that the impression comes from source bias: Cicero's well-preserved speeches and letters make late-Republican trials unusually visible. Livy shows that politically driven prosecutions of former magistrates were routine and even necessary for accountability from the Middle Republic back to 451. What actually changed was Caesar's long command, which bought him both legal immunity and a loyal army. The post closes with brief comments on historiography's citation canon and a detailed recommendation of Champlin's study of Roman wills.
It pairs careful reasoning about ancient sources with a clear lesson in survivorship bias, the kind of evidence-driven history essay this reader values, though housekeeping notes pad it out.
fit 8 · substance 7 · originality 6 · importance 6 · writing 7
- 5History & culture6.1
Modern warfare
Occasionally a book gets the next war right. In 1937, Heinz Guderian argued in Achtung – Panzer! that tanks should concentrate in armored formations, that those formations were best controlled by radio, and that their purpose was to break through enemy lines and fight beyond them. In 1940, Guderian used a German tank…
Why it's here
A short, clear piece that sums up Watling's thesis on sensor-dominated war and checks it against Ukraine. Worth a quick read, though it is closer to a book précis than an original argument.
Jack Watling's The Arms of the Future argues that better sensors, longer weapon range and more precise munitions have made it impossible to combine surprise and concentration, which modern militaries have long relied on. Armies are left with three options: disperse and dig in, retreat into cities, or fight the enemy's sensors to open a brief window for attack. The piece opens with Guderian's prediction of tank warfare as a parallel. It then shows Ukraine bearing Watling out: soldiers living underground, a preference for fighting from towns, heavy Russian losses, and early success for units that blind enemy sensors first.
It fits the reader's interest in the history of technology, showing concretely how precision and sensing technology are reshaping war, with good comparative figures.
fit 6 · substance 6 · originality 5 · importance 7 · writing 8
- 6History & culture5.9
“Earth Not a Globe”: Parallax’s Zetetic Astronomy (1865)
Parallax, Zetetic Astronomy. Earth Not a Globe! An Experimental Inquiry into the True Figure of the Earth: Proving it a Plane, Without Axial or Orbital Motion; and the Only Material World in the Universe! (London: Simkin, Marshall, and Co., 1865).How sincere are flat earthers, really? When “Saddam Hussein” posted on…
Why it's here
A short, witty piece on the Victorian flat-earth showman Parallax that raises an interesting question about sincerity and contrarianism, though it's too brief to dig into it.
The piece opens with a long-running parody flat-earth poster and asks how sincere flat-earthers really are. It then turns to Samuel Birley Rowbotham ('Parallax'), whose 1865 Zetetic Astronomy became the founding text of modern flat-earth belief. It covers his Bedford Level canal experiment, his explanations for away the usual proofs of a round earth, and his religious framing. Drawing on historian Christine Garwood, it suggests that his success came less from conviction than from his skill at embarrassing pompous experts in public debate, and that people at the time doubted he believed his own theory.
It's a well-told vignette from the history of science and contrarian persuasion, the sort of curious episode this reader likes, though it's thin on analysis.
fit 7 · substance 5 · originality 6 · importance 4 · writing 7
Philosophy & ideas
- 1Philosophy & ideas7.2
Believing and thinking
The idea of separating church and state – now entrenched in many modern liberal democracies – is in some ways strange. After all, governments must keep themselves informed and inform their citizens. That’s why they turn to the science of meteorology to predict weather patterns, to economics to understand patterns of…
Why it's here
Worth reading: it takes a sharp empirical-philosophical distinction between religious credence and factual belief and uses it to make a fresh case for church–state separation, though the political step is lighter than the psychological one.
Van Leeuwen and Eisler argue that what sets religious belief apart is not its content but the attitude behind it. Drawing on cognitive science, ethnography and linguistics, they set out three differences: religious credence is chosen, holds up against evidence and is switched on mainly in sacred settings, while factual belief is involuntary, responds to evidence and guides action all the time. They then use this to justify both halves of the First Amendment. Because religious credence doesn't respond to evidence, it can't take part in democratic deliberation, so the state shouldn't establish a religion. Because it is compartmentalised, believers can set it aside in public life, which makes free exercise workable.
It brings philosophy of mind, empirical psychology and political theory together in a clear, argued long-form essay, the cross-disciplinary kind of ideas piece this reader values.
fit 8 · substance 7 · originality 7 · importance 6 · writing 7
- 2Philosophy & ideas5.8
The Souls of Animals
“They do not sweat and whine about their condition,” Walt Whitman wrote of the other animals, “they do not lie awake in the dark and weep for their sins, they do not make me sick discussing their duty to God, not one is dissatisfied, not one is demented with the mania of owning things.”
Why it's here
A lyrical, quote-rich look back at Gary Kowalski's 1991 book on animal spirituality, with memorable anecdotes but more reverence than rigorous argument.
Popova revisits Gary Kowalski's The Souls of Animals, which defines soul as moral sense, aesthetic appreciation, creativity and a sense of wonder, and argues that other animals share these traits. Kowalski's evidence is anecdotal: birdsong treated as music, Siri the elephant's drawings that an art professor compared to de Kooning (later the subject of a May Sarton poem), and terns carrying a wounded companion to shore. It ends with Kowalski's claim that humans need other creatures in order to know themselves, which gives the argument an existential edge as well as an ecological one. As usual for The Marginalian, Whitman, Woolf, Murdoch, Carson and others are woven through it.
It brings together philosophy, nature writing and poetry in a way this reader likes, though the scientific side of animal cognition stays thin.
fit 7 · substance 5 · originality 5 · importance 5 · writing 7
Psychology & mind
- 1Psychology & mind6.7
Baby heaven
The young woman sitting in front of me is sure she is dead. It – her dying – happened two weeks ago, she says. Now she simply doesn’t exist.
Why it's here
A moving, well-made personal essay that links clinical delusion, belief and a trans child's self-authorship, though it is more memoir than argument.
A clinical psychologist who studies delusions remembers how he once called religious belief delusional and how drawn he was to claims that rising gender dysphoria is a 'culture-bound' social contagion. Then his young child comes out as trans and explains, through a homemade cosmology called 'Baby Heaven', that he picked the wrong gender before birth. Thinking back to the taboos of his boarding school, the author comes to see the rise in trans identification as mostly a wave of visibility, not delusion. He closes with a children's book about a bunyip told it doesn't exist, and says that denying trans children exist can feel to them like annihilation.
It brings together psychology, philosophy of belief and literary memoir in elegant prose, which suits a reader who values beautifully written essays across fields, even though the evidence is light.
fit 7 · substance 6 · originality 7 · importance 6 · writing 8
- 2Psychology & mind6.7
How psychology’s classic studies misled us about the self
Imagine a creature that is like humans in every way, except that it has no enduring inner self. The behaviour of this hypothetical species – which we will call Homo vacuus – would be driven not by their private beliefs and inclinations, but rather by knee-jerk responses to their immediate environment. Lacking an…
Why it's here
A clear, well-framed critique of situationist psychology. It is worth reading, though it covers familiar replication-crisis ground and its evidence is gestured at more than laid out.
The authors invent 'Homo vacuus', a creature with no enduring inner self, and use it to show the 'empty-self' assumption behind social priming and situationist psychology. They trace this view from behaviourism through Milgram and the Stanford prison experiment. The case against it rests on replication failures, their own finding that empty-self studies replicate less often, reinterpretations of the classic studies, and the stability of personality traits. They argue for interactionism, the view that person and situation together shape behaviour, and point to personalised second-generation nudges as one result.
It speaks directly to the reader's interest in psychology and decision-making and in careful reasoning about evidence, with implications for policy such as nudging.
fit 8 · substance 6 · originality 6 · importance 6 · writing 7
- 3Psychology & mind6.1
I Feel, Therefore I Am: Neuroscientist Antonio Damasio the Consciousness of the Body
“Ultimately, we are puppets of both pain and pleasure, occasionally made free by our creativity.”
Why it's here
A lyrical, quote-heavy tour of Damasio's embodied theory of consciousness, good as an introduction but thin as critical analysis.
Popova summarises Antonio Damasio's Feeling & Knowing, which argues that consciousness is neither confined to brain activity nor beyond scientific reach. In this view it comes from feelings, the nervous system's ongoing dialogue with the body's homeostatic state. She traces the evolutionary sequence Damasio describes, from being to feeling to knowing, and frames it with Dickinson, Whitman, William James, Nussbaum and Arendt. She then draws her own conclusions: the theory undercuts belief in immortal souls, mind uploading and machine consciousness, and challenges human exceptionalism and IQ-based hierarchies.
It pairs neuroscience with poetry and philosophy in long-form prose, which suits this reader's interest in mind, science writing and literature, though the reader should know it summarises rather than evaluates the book.
fit 8 · substance 5 · originality 4 · importance 6 · writing 7
- 4Psychology & mind5.5
Methodical/mercurial
How would it be if you woke up one morning around 4 am, consumed by an idea that felt like the Best Idea You Ever Had. You spend the next two hours fervently researching said idea, watching videos, reading in-depth articles, compiling a spreadsheet comparing costs, techniques and options, then buying a whole load of…
Why it's here
A warm, vivid first-person account of living with both autism and ADHD, with some history of diagnosis, though the research side is thin and partly promotes the author's book.
The author explains that a dual autism–ADHD diagnosis (AuDHD) has only been allowed since DSM-5 in 2013, and that adult diagnoses of either condition are also fairly recent. She says the two conditions overlap a lot and share genetic roots, but the research is sparse, focused on children, and frames everything as deficit. Drawing on her own life and interviews with 69 people, she describes AuDHD as a push and pull between needing routine and needing novelty. She also argues the pairing can bring creativity and joy.
It's an accessible, well-written piece of psychology and lived experience, though the reader will find little rigorous evidence or new analysis.
fit 6 · substance 5 · originality 5 · importance 5 · writing 7
Economics & society
- 1Economics & society6.4
Why I’m becoming a China bear
When I tell people I’m becoming a China bear, they’re often surprised. “Weren’t you already a China bear?” they ask me.
Why it's here
An argued change of mind from a well-known China bull on why the manufacturing push is running out of room, though the paywall cuts off the AI section the author calls his main reason.
Noah Smith explains why he has moved from China bull to China bear. He now doubts China can become a global hegemon or win the race for technological dominance. In the visible part, he argues that Xi's plan to make China the 'make-everything country' is hitting its limits. China is too big to rely on exports the way South Korea does, so its factories depend on a domestic market that the property bust has weakened. Subsidies have left industries with too much capacity and collapsing profits, and infrastructure building has peaked, leaving heavy upkeep costs. The AI argument and the political argument are behind the paywall.
It suits the reader's interest in economics, policy and geopolitics, and the author reasons openly with data about why he changed his mind, though the most AI-relevant part is missing.
fit 7 · substance 6 · originality 6 · importance 6 · writing 7
- 2Economics & society5.9
The Challenges of Laissez-Faire Democracy
Economists are frequently accused of being advocates for unfettered and unregulated laissez-faire markets, but anyone who has ever taken a basic introductory economics class knows that this caricature is untrue. The basic intro econ class does spend time on explaining what markets do well. It also spends considerable…
Why it's here
A short, clear summary of a provocative paper that turns market-failure reasoning on democracy, though it is mostly long quotations with little commentary of its own.
Drawing on Brennan and Freiman's paper "Against laissez-faire democracy," the post argues that the market failures used to justify economic regulation also show up in elections. These include public goods, information asymmetry, principal-agent problems, limited competition and externalities. It lists the regulatory fixes the paper suggests for each one, such as voting stipends, promise registries, randomised ballots and supermajority safeguards. It ends on the authors' point about consistency: if fear of capture rules out regulating democracy, the same fear should apply to regulating markets.
It brings together economics, policy and political philosophy and offers a reframing that sticks, which suits a reader who likes original arguments in political economy.
fit 7 · substance 5 · originality 6 · importance 5 · writing 6
Technology & software
- 1Technology & software6.0
How software engineering is changing: a tale of two eras
Before we start: I’m in San Francisco this week and there are a few remaining spots for these live events (registration required):
Why it's here
A useful, data-backed first-person account of AI-native engineering work, but it is one engineer's story at a very small startup and is framed by housekeeping and event promotion.
Neil Kakkar compares his output at Bloomberg, PostHog and the AI-native startup Tano using his own pull-request data. He shows that he merged about 11 times more PRs at Tano, where he works through Claude Code agents with only automated code review. He argues that removing human review and coordination overhead, not AI alone, is what unlocks the gain, and he admits the costs: production bugs fixed after release, constant task-switching, lost shared knowledge across the team, mental exhaustion and generic AI-generated design. He concludes that a company's culture and its willingness to remove new bottlenecks decide whether AI adoption pays off.
It is a concrete, evidence-based look at how AI is changing knowledge work and the economics of technology, with honest attention to its costs to people and organisations, though it leans toward practitioner detail.
fit 6 · substance 6 · originality 6 · importance 6 · writing 6